| 2006 Topps Heritage Jonathan Papelbon SP Rookie Red Sox |
| 2006 Topps Jonathan Jon Papelbon Rookie RC Red Sox |
| 2006 Bowman Heritage Chrome Jonathan Papelbon Rookie |
| 2006 TOPPS TURKEY RED JONATHAN PAPELBON ROOKIE RED SOX |
| 2006 Tradition - Jonathan Papelbon - Red Sox Rookie |
| 2006 FLEER TRADITIONAL JONATHAN PAPELBON ROOKIE CARD p |
| 2006 Bazooka Jonathan Jon Papelbon Rookie RC Red Sox |
| 2006 UPPER DECK JONATHAN PAPELBON ROOKIE CARD p |
| 2006 Flair Showcase Jonathan Papelbon Rookie RC #73 |
| 2006 Topps Turkey Red Jonathan Papelbon Rookie RC #608 |
| 2006 BOWMAN CHROME #206 JONATHAN PAPELBON ROOKIE |
| 2006 TOPPS JONATHAN PAPELBON Rookie Card No.355 |
| 2006 Topps - Jonathan Papelbon - Red Sox Rookie |
| 2006 Topps Chrome Jonathan Moore Black Rookie Refractor |
| 2006 JONATHAN ORR SAGE HIT ROOKIE WISCONSIN BADGERS |
| 2006 Topps Chrome Jonathan Papelbon # 314 rookie card |
| 2006 TOPPS TURKEY RED JONATHAN PAPELBON ROOKIE RED SOX |
| 2006 TURKEY RED JONATHAN PAPELBON ROOKIE CARD RED SOX!! |
| 2006 Press Pass Jonathan Orr Autographed Rookie Card |
| 2006 Playoff Prestige Jonathan Joseph Bengals Rookie RC |
| 2006 TOPPS 52 JONATHAN PAPELBON Signature Rookie Card |