| Scott Rolen 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers 28 |
| Jim Thome 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers #2 ; $ |
| Todd Helton 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers 25 |
| Adrian Beltre 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers 2 |
| Sammy Sosa 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers #4 ; |
| Kerry Wood 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers 26 ; |
| Vladimir Guerrero 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Game |
| Gary Sheffield 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers |
| Curt Schilling 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers |
| Nomar Garciaparra 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Game |
| Alfonso Soriano 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers |
| Hank Blalock 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers 5 |
| Scott Rolen 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers #28 |
| Sammy Sosa 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers 4 ; |
| Manny Ramirez 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers 1 |
| Miguel Tejada 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers 3 |
| Rafael Palmeiro 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers |
| Jim Thome 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers 2 ; $ |
| Carlos Beltran 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers |
| Curt Schilling 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers |
| Randy Johnson 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers 6 |
| Jim Thome 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers #2 ; |
| Rafael Palmeiro 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers |
| Pedro Martinez 2005 National Pastime Grand Old Gamers |